Call Pittsburgh Office (412) 281-8400

Call NY Office (212) 952-0014

Toll Free (888) 355-1735

Call Pittsburgh Office (412) 281-8400


Early Retirement Pension Benefits

Comments Off on Early Retirement Pension Benefits

Former Employees of United Refining Company Win Early Retirement Pension Benefits Class Action in Federal Court in Western Pennsylvania.


Feinstein Doyle Payne & Kravec attorneys recently won an early retirement pension benefits class action on behalf of a group of former employees of United Refining Company.

The former employees, represented by Tybe Brett and Joel Hurt, had worked for United Refining for years but had left the company prior to their retirement age.  At the time they left the company, each was promised unreduced early retirement pension benefits.
After years of interpreting its pension plan to provide unreduced benefits to the affected employees, in 2005 and 2006 the company changed its course and stopped paying unreduced benefits to these employees.
Two of the employees brought a class action lawsuit alleging that United Refining violated federal pension law by reducing or “cutting back” their accrued pension benefits.  In April 2013, the Court ruled in favor of the two named plaintiffs.
Click here to review the April 8, 2013 Opinion: United Refining Summary Judgment Opinion
The Court found that the company’s initial interpretation that the former employees were entitled to unreduced early retirement pension benefits was rational.  It also found that United Refining’s reinterpretation of the pension plan was unreasonable and rendered key plan language meaningless.
On November 5, 2013, the Court extended the named plaintiffs’ victory to a “class” of approximately 175 former employees.  The Court awarded injunctive relief to all class members, forcing the company to provide unreduced early retirement benefits to each of them.
The Court also required the pension plan to reimburse those class members who had received a reduced benefit, in an amount equal to the difference between what they should have been paid and what they were actually paid, plus interest at 7.5%.
Click here to review the Court’s November 5, 2013 Order:   Memorandum and Order
The parties are now in the process of determining precisely who is in the class and the amounts of past benefits owed to approximately 30 class members who had been paid reduced early retirement pension benefits.  Once those issues are resolved, it is likely that United Refining and its pension plan will appeal the Court’s decisions.

Comments are closed


Feinstein Doyle Payne & Kravec, LLC

Pittsburgh Office

429 Fourth Avenue, Suite 1300

Pittsburgh, PA 15219

Phone: +1 (412) 281-8400

Toll Free: +1 (888) 355-1735

Fax: +1 (412) 281-1007

New York Office

29 Broadway, 24th Floor

New York, NY 10006-3205

Phone: +1 (212) 952-0014